Wine Radar
How the Wine Radar Visitor Awards are decided
The Visitor Awards are about the visit: the welcome, the tasting, the food, the stay and how easy it is to come by bike or on foot. We do not judge the wine. Taking part is free, nobody can apply or pay for an award, and the method is the same for every winery on the map.
Three levels
Guests' Choice is calculated each year for each region from verified visits and guests' ratings of the visit. The regional jury selection is chosen by a public jury in the region from the top 30 % of the Guests' Choice ranking and from guests' nominations. The world selection is chosen by an international expert jury from the regional winners, after anonymous test visits.
How a visit is verified
A visit only counts when a signed-in guest checks in with the phone at the winery: the position must be within the winery area and accurate enough. Visits added later from the phone, check-ins with too fast movement between places and check-ins that look like a faked position are not counted. Only the day of the visit is shown publicly; the exact time and position are deleted after 90 days.
How ratings are counted
Only a guest with a verified visit can rate that visit, from 1 to 5, within 30 days, once per winery and year. A winery needs at least 10 verified visits (more in regions with many visitors, at most 30) and ratings from at least 60 % of that number. The score is a weighted average (Bayesian): a winery with few ratings is pulled towards the region average, so a handful of enthusiastic ratings is not enough. The region average is used when the region has at least 50 ratings. The weighted score must be at least 4.0 of 5.
How many can receive an award
At most 10 % of the wineries in a region can be Guests' Choice. In the jury and world levels at most 30 % of the candidates in a category receive a distinction, the same ceiling as the rules of the International Organisation of Vine and Wine (OIV) for competitions. A region gets no award at all until it has at least 200 verified visits in the year and at least 3 wineries that meet the requirements. Until then the page says: not enough verified visits yet.
Who may not vote or rate
The winery itself, its owners and staff (for example addresses on the winery's own domain), owners of other wineries in the same region, sponsors and their staff, and jury members for wineries they have a connection to. Jury members sign a declaration of interests that is published.
Payment never affects the result
The award is free. Wineries cannot apply, and Plus, Pro, a claimed page, a tasting request, the optional winners package and sponsorship never change the calculation or the jury. The calculation does not even receive this information.
Sponsors
A tourist board or consortium can support a category, globally or in a region. It is then shown as "In cooperation with …". A sponsor never sees results in advance, never influences who wins and never sits on a jury.
How we detect cheating
We look for unusual patterns: many ratings in a short time, many new accounts with only one visit, several accounts from the same device, many accounts from the same network that rate the same winery, and check-ins without real presence (the same exact position for several people, or a position exactly on our map pin). Suspicious ratings are not counted, and a winery with unusual patterns is reviewed before it can receive an award.
The jury
Each region has a public jury of local guides, sommeliers and writers with a chair. A part of the voting members is replaced every year, and nobody sits for more than three years in a row. Each member gives 3, 2 and 1 points in each category; a vote needs at least 3 members. The world jury is international and also uses anonymous test visits made according to a written protocol, paid by Wine Radar.
Sustainability only with certification
We only give a sustainability distinction to wineries with a valid certification from a recognised scheme (for example EU organic or a national sustainability certification), and we name the certification. Without certification there is no sustainability award.
Corrections and complaints
If you think something is wrong, write to olle@wineradar.net. We answer, correct mistakes and publish changes in the method with a date.
Method version 2026-1.
Badge for your website
Winners can show the badge on their own website for free. It links to the method.
Cite as: Wine Radar (wineradar.net), “How the Wine Radar Visitor Awards are decided”, https://wineradar.net/visitor-awards/method/ (data last changed 2026-11-14).